Whitewood vs yellow pine However, the grain pattern can be more challenging to paint evenly compared to other softwoods. So the pine will sag less with the same weight. In spruce, needles are attached to the branch individually. Pine tends to be the more durable option for home building and flooring, making it the more expensive option. Whitewood has a Janka of 540 whereas yellow pine has a rating of 690. Ash (Black) 850. Even in homes that use spruce or fir for the frame will often use pine wood for any exposed areas. Shedua: 710. Southern yellow pine (Janka rating 870 lbf), for instance, is even harder than many hardwoods. It’s typically a warmer yellow than eastern white pine, with pronounced brown grain lines. When buying "whitewood" you'll get one of these. Red and Ponderosa Pine - Less strong than SYP, found in northern U. This is why it is used for floor joists. This is a dialog window which overlays the main content of the page. Here’s a breakdown: AD or S-GRN: Air-dried According to the Engineering Tool Box website. This may at times also be referred to as yellow poplar. Lowes states that their white wood could be spruce, pine, or fir. It has the highest bending strength & compression strength of any softwood seen throughout North America. The thing to remember is that whitewood pine at the BORG could be any number of species, like lodgepole pine ponderosa pine and I've even seen grand fir or spruce thrown in there as well. 12-05-2001, 05:06 PM Cedar Vs Pine: The Ultimate Comparison Cedar Vs Pine Color. Framing lumber should be stamped and you will see SPF on the stamp. Other good species choices include: Southern Yellow Pine (SYP actually four or five different pine species) Larch (usually grouped with Doug-fir) Hemlock & Fir (Hem-Fir) On the other hand, whitewood, also known as southern yellow pine, is lighter in color and has more knots. It all works. Leopardwood: 840. Technically speaking, white wood lumber stems from the American tulip tree or the liriodendron tulipifera. And we will compare pine vs whitewood in this post. Dimensional SPF lumber is used for wood framing. Cedar is more expensive than pine, but is more durable and lasts longer. SP&F woods are generally much more stable than most of As you can probably guess, the biggest difference between these two types of wood is that eastern white pine is much lighter in color than redwood, which features a reddish-brown color. Breaking Down the Hardness of Different Softwoods. Regarding woodworking and home improvement projects, few things matter as much as the wood you use. If you use pressure-treated pine, just be sure to use fasteners rated for The wood from the American tulip tree or yellow poplar is known as whitewood, and it’s one of the world’s tallest hardwoods. Yellow Pine end grain hardwood floor- It can range in color from light yellow to reddish-brown, and it has a more distinct and visible grain pattern than whitewood. The most common species of dimensional building lumber (e. This type of wood is sourced from the tallest hardwood trees that can grow up to 160 feet in height. Southern Yellow Pine (short leaf) 690. It can withstand heavy foot traffic and is highly resistant to scratches and dents. Comment. Its incredible strength allows builders to accomplish more with less wood. Step 3: Steelwool & Vinegar. I would follow the guidelines from the engineer associated with the building. The $$$ difference used to be on the order of 18-20%, but now it's much lower. Difference Between Whitewood vs Pine. Grade #2 is the better of the two; it has fewer knots and wider widths than grade #3. SPF (spruce-pine-fir) would be used for the wall studs. but the most remarkable difference is between the standard white oaks and the live oaks of the southeastern US. The fact that it is from the tallest tree makes it that much more popular and special. This is why yellow pine is sometimes sold as whitewood in some places. This is the real difference between whitewood and pine as far as your lumberyard is concerned. COMMODE. And it is important that the lumber be stacked with stickers between the boards and weight on top while they are drying, so it can dry evenly and flat. Southern yellow pine: Also known as longleaf pine, this is the densest of these three pines, with a Janka rating of 870 lbf. Most Big Box Home Improvement stores carry White Pine sometimes Whitewood vs dimensional; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. The properties of spruce and pine differ, as you will see below. Its grain, while attractive enough, tends not to telegraph through paint, and since only the knot-free portions are generally OVERVIEW. Whitewood boards are easily cut, machined, sanded and fastened with hand or power tools. Lowes: Whitewood Softwood Board. Useful in light construction or crafts where knotty lumber with a fine appearance is desired. Sugar pine is prevalent in the western region of the United States. extra cautious, though, you could consider anything with "cedar" in the name, or cypress, or pressure-treated southern yellow pine, or douglas fir. Radiata is somewhat stronger than Eastern White Pine but less hard than Southern Yellow Pine, making it a good choice for trim boards and moldings where enhanced sturdiness is desirable but easy workability still valued. Very easy to nail due to the low density. ) and usually are cut from higher quality logs. Honestly if you're just cutting and gluing pieces for something simple, pine is typically gonna look nicer, it stains better, and you won't know the difference at the end of the day. It is often seen woodworkers getting confused between choosing whitewood and pine. Main Menu As cfarm said, deeper creates strength in bending, that 2x8 is almost twice as strong in bending compared to a 4x4. Another difference is that whitewood is a bit heavier and denser than cedar, with cedar coming in at roughly 19-21 lbs per square foot, whereas whitewood weighs around 29 lbs per square foot. Other names whitewood may be referred to include tulip tree, tulip poplar, yellow poplar, American tulip tree, and fiddle tree. . Both pine and whitewood accept stains and finishes Whitewood is technically the type of lumber that comes from the tulip tree, also known as the American tulip tree or the yellow poplar. Unfinished, ready to paint or stain. Douglas Fir is known for its higher strength and density compared to Southern Yellow Pine. Post Cancel. Spruce, pine, and fir are collectively known as SPF. Spruce is a light-colored wood that has a little variation between sapwood, heartwood. Weight The weight between the two types of wood varies, with pinewood being the heavier one. It is creamy in its coloration, though it can range from a milky white to a more yellowish color- Southern Yellow Pine (SYP) Southern yellow pine has a more pronounced, visually striking grain pattern with a yellowish hue. Premium Subscriber ; Posts: 32; I'm new! Cleaning and maintaining Yellow Pine vs. 7367. Whitewood is a general term used to describe various light-colored softwoods, such as spruce, fir, and cedar. It is mostly known for the plywood it makes. has a creamy-white to yellow sapwood and a pale yellowish-brown to reddish-brown heartwood. I recently went into The Home Depot for some 2x4s. Yellow pine provides an outstanding combination of power and weight. 406. First, we have whitewood, which technically refers to the lumber that comes from the tulip tree, or the American tulip tree. Orthotropic Nature of Wood Wood may be described as an orthotropic material; that is, it has unique and independent mechanical properties in the directions of three mutually perpendicular axes: longitudi-nal, radial, and tangential. The pressure SYP can take without breaking (MOR) is 12,800 pounds per square inch (psi). The appearance is so Yellow Pine. And Eastern Pine fairs even worse in terms of its compressional strength, with a Janka rating of only 380 lbf. Due to this difference in hardness, whitewood is a bit more resistant to impact, denting, and scratching than cedar. Anyway the white wood is alittle cheaper but doesnt look as good as the yellow. In the grand scheme of things, this is of course more a matter of personal preference than anything else. By "whitewood," I believe you mean poplar, or more accurately, wood from the tulip poplar tree, Liriodendron tulipifera. Both Cedar and Pine wood, depending on the species, can vary in hardness, While pine generally falls within the range of 380 to 870 lbf, the Janka rating of cedar ranges from 320 to 900 lbf. 2x4s was marked $2. As someone else said, you will find better lumber (straighter grain In charleston, Man, that's all they had was yellow pine, for framing, up to 2x10's then some fir 2x12's, . Some examples include pine, spruce, hemlock, fir, and Southern Yellow Pine (SYP). The white stuff has almost no odor /scent while the yellow pine smells distinctively like turpentine when you cut into it. Douglas Fir. It’s slightly harder and heavier than white pine but much less so than southern pine. Another approach is to measure the deformation or strain that results from a given level of stress before the point of total failure. Pine Comparisons Whitewood is cut from the fastest growing and tallest hardwood tree there is. Yellow pine is stronger and heartier, but warps more than Pinewood vs. Kiln drying will get out a lot of the moisture content but not necessarily the resin. I think the southern yellow pine is more expensive than spruce or white pine. In the following chart (chart 1) you will note that cedar weights Basic Differences Between White Fir And Douglas Fir Lumber. From Eastern white pine, the ponderosas and the Longleaf yellow pine to the Russian redwoods of Eastern Europe, we find dovetailed tool chests in the holds of ancient sailing vessels and long-case clocks on the walls of manorial hallways. Are you getting confused about what to choose between white wood or yellow pine? Planet ECO team is here to guide you about both wood's advantages and disadvantages! When it comes to whitewood vs. Most 2-by-4s are made with pine, so there is a good chance that pine makes up the frame of your home. Pine may also have more knots and resin canals. Guest #14. Started by Sedgehammer, May 11, 2021, 10:50:14 AM. These days, I only see spruce in my area. SYP is also considered non-durable, has large knots and loose grain patterns. Poplar is used as a higher quality substitute for pine in painted trim and millwork Maple is used where material strength and dimensional stability are desired such as in cabinetry and furniture. As far as Yellow Pine being ugly, that right there is why they make both chocolate and vanilla ice cream. The first difference between cedar and pine can be seen with the naked eye. Whitewood: Known as: Pinus Sylvestris Liriodendron Tulipifera White Wood vs. Senior Member x2; Posts: 2,417; Old enough to know better, but ya only live once! 8-ft 6-ft 4-ft 10-ft 12-ft Poplar Pine Cedar Red oak Oak Maple Spruce pine fir Hickory Walnut Cherry White oak Ash Eastern white pine Radiata pine Hemlock Whitewood Southern yellow pine Teak Douglas fir Redwood Mahogany Hemlock fir Alder Birch Cypress Euro spruce Unfinished Stained Woodworking Projects Furniture & Cabinets Shelving Exterior Wood Density and Specific Gravity The Following chart will tell you how much weight you can expect from your wood selection. What is nice is that both of these types of wood are fairly affordable, with eastern white pine costing you between $7 and $10 per board foot, and eastern hemlock costing between $3. Model 1058 - Custom Bathroom Vanity Made by Limitless Woodworking It's extremely straight, clear grain pine. The elevation of the tree is what makes it one of the most useful wood trees on the planet. There is a small density difference between whitewood vs. To me "Fir" is Douglas Fir. SPF is also called "whitewood", meaning some conifer of Southern Yellow Pine (SYP) Lastly is SYP which has a high prevalence, especially in North America. acbjyns uxao xuzt buxsud ocvzrbd zazgosij oao gan xwt vmrn lcjan vdynt hnkqn vyfij vntjotpq